E-commerce Email Marketing Best Practices: Boosting Opens, Clicks & Conversions
- Kerri Cuthbert
- Sep 26
- 26 min read
Email marketing remains one of the highest-ROI channels for e-commerce. In fact, 35% of companies see returns of over £36 for every £1 spent on email. But success isn’t just about sending more emails – it’s about sending better emails. In this guide, we’ll explore proven strategies to increase your open rates, click-through rates (CTR), and sales conversions. We’ll also dive into psychological tactics (like urgency, FOMO, social proof, and anchoring) that influence buyer behavior, plus tactical tips on subject lines, timing, segmentation, design, and more. These insights come backed by marketing research and case studies, and they’re applicable not only to online retailers but to any business looking to spark engagement and drive action. Let’s jump in!
Crafting Irresistible Subject Lines to Increase Open Rates
The subject line is your first (and sometimes only) chance to grab a subscriber’s attention. Nearly 50% of emails are opened based on the subject line alone, so a compelling subject is critical for lifting open rates. Here are key tactics to boost your email opens:
Inspire Curiosity: Pique interest with subject lines that tease or ask questions. For example, “Did you see this yet?” can outperform feature-heavy headlines because people feel compelled to find out more. Creating an information gap encourages the open – humans are naturally curious and want to fill in the blanks.
Personalise When Possible: Including the recipient’s name or other personal detail can increase the sense of relevance. “Alex, a special offer for you” feels personal and often outperforms generic lines. Be genuine – personalisation works best when it feels natural and tailored, not like a mass mail merge gimmick.
Keep It Short (but Test Length): Aim for concise subject lines (about 5-7 words) that are easy to read at a glance. That said, don’t be afraid to A/B test short vs. longer subject lines. In some cases, a longer, specific subject (“What 2,400 CMOs are doing differently in 2025”) can outperform a short one by providing more context. The key is to convey compelling info without getting cut off – and testing will reveal what your audience prefers.
Avoid Spam Traps: Certain “spammy” keywords and styles (like all caps or multiple exclamation points) can send your email to the junk folder. Words like “Free!!!” or “Urgent” in the subject may hurt deliverability. Urgency can be created without literally using the word “Urgent” – for example, use action verbs and time references (“Ends tonight: 50% off storewide”) to convey urgency without triggering spam filters.
Use Emojis and Humor (Strategically): Depending on your brand voice, a well-placed emoji or a touch of humor can make your email stand out in a crowded inbox. A lighthearted subject that makes someone smile can improve opens. Just ensure it aligns with your audience; humor should enhance, not undermine, your message.
Leverage the Preheader Text: Don’t neglect the preview text (the snippet that appears next to or below the subject in many email clients). Use it to extend your subject line’s message or add a tempting detail. For instance, if the subject is “Mystery Deal Inside!”, the preheader might say “Surprise discount for loyal customers – today only.” This one-two punch can persuade a user to open.
Optimise Timing and Consistency: When you send can be just as important as what you send. Research shows the best time to send marketing emails is generally mid-morning (around 9am–12pm), with a secondary window early afternoon. Of course, ideal timing can vary by audience – consider your subscribers’ time zones and behaviors. Many marketers use send-time optimisation tools or simply test different send times to see when engagement is highest. Also, be consistent – if subscribers learn to expect your newsletter every Friday at 10 AM, you’re “training” them to look for it, and open rates can rise with that familiarity.
Segment for Relevance: Don’t blast everyone with the same message. By segmenting your list (for example, by past purchase history, location, or engagement level), you can send more targeted emails that naturally get higher opens. An engaged segment (e.g. recent purchasers) will open more frequently than a cold segment. Building these engaged segments also improves deliverability, since more opens and clicks signal to email providers that your messages are wanted. In short, send the right content to the right people. For instance, a clothing retailer might send a “Winter Sale” subject line only to subscribers in colder climates – it’s more likely to resonate and be opened by that group.
Finally, always be testing. Even small tweaks can have a big impact. One campaign saw an open rate jump of 11% just by adding a time reference (“...before Friday”) to the subject line, making the offer feel timely. Try A/B testing different approaches – curiosity vs. straightforward, personalised vs. generic, question vs. statement – and let the data inform your subject line strategy.
Boosting Click-Through Rates: Engaging Email Content & CTAs
Getting the open is just step one; the real payoff comes from the click-through. The average email CTR in retail e-commerce is around 1–2%, but you can outperform that by applying some best practices in your email content and design. Here’s how to turn more opens into clicks:
Have a Single, Clear Call-to-Action: It’s tempting to pack emails with multiple links – new products, sale items, “learn more” buttons, etc. But too many choices can actually suppress action. In fact, emails with one clear CTA can see up to a 371% increase in clicks compared to emails with several competing links. Decide on the one primary goal of your email (e.g. “Shop the Sale”) and focus your content around driving that action. You can include a secondary link (like in the footer), but make the main CTA unmissable.
Make Your CTA Stand Out (Use Buttons): Don’t hide your call-to-action in text. A bold, clickable button outperforms a text link, especially on mobile. Use a contrasting color that aligns with your brand but grabs attention, and make the button text action-oriented (e.g., “Shop Now” or “Get 20% Off” rather than a dull “Submit”). Ensure the button looks obviously tappable – clear enough for even a quick-scrolling thumb to spot and click.
Position It Early (and Repeat It): Many subscribers don’t scroll through an entire email. Place your primary CTA near the top (“above the fold”) so that it’s seen without requiring extensive scrolling. For longer newsletter-style emails, you can repeat the CTA at the end as well – giving both skimmers and thorough readers a convenient place to click. Importantly, keep the call-to-action messaging consistent each time (don’t confuse people with different wording).
Lead with Benefits (“What’s in it for me?”): Frame your email content and CTA around the reader’s benefit. Instead of “Our Latest Updates” or a generic “Learn More,” phrase it as what the user gains: “See Your Exclusive Offers” or “Upgrade Your Wardrobe Today”. For example, “See your growth report” will entice more clicks than “Check out our latest update”, because it centers on the value to the reader. Continuously answer that unspoken question every subscriber has: “Why should I click this?”.
Use Engaging Visuals (But Keep Layout Clean): In e-commerce, visuals sell. Use high-quality images of products or lifestyle shots that support your message – these can draw the eye and create desire. However, be careful with layout: a single-column design with plenty of white space often works best, especially for mobile. Surround your CTA with whitespace to make it pop. Every element in the email should ultimately drive toward the click, not distract from it. Infographics or GIFs can also boost engagement if relevant (just keep file sizes small for fast loading).
Add Social Proof for Credibility: If appropriate, incorporate a snippet of social proof near your call-to-action. A short customer testimonial, review rating, or mention of popularity (“Join 50,000+ happy subscribers” or “#1 choice for moms”) can give hesitant readers an extra push. Seeing that others trust or value your product reduces fear of clicking through. Even a tiny stat or quote below the CTA can boost click rates by reinforcing trust. For example, a CTA button followed by “★★★★★ Rated 4.8/5 by 1,200 customers” combines a clear action with reassurance.
Make Emails Mobile-Friendly: With about 41% of email views now happening on mobile devices, a mobile-optimised design is a must for high CTR. Use larger fonts and tappable elements. Buttons should be big enough to tap with a thumb, and links spaced out to avoid mis-taps. Test your emails on a phone to see how easy it is to scroll and click. If an email isn’t easy to read or interact with on mobile, many users will simply delete it – or worse, unsubscribe.
Test, Test, Test (Design & Copy): Continuously A/B test different content elements to see what drives more clicks. Try variations of your button colour, size, or wording. Test using an image vs. an animated GIF vs. plain text to see what resonates. Perhaps a shorter email (just a bold header, a product image, and a CTA) might outperform a longer, detailed one – or vice versa. Regular testing of design and content elements will uncover what your specific audience responds to. For instance, one study found personalised CTAs converted 202% better than generic ones, so testing personalisation in your call-to-action copy could yield big gains.
Key takeaway: Clarity and focus drive clicks. An email should guide the reader’s eyes to one action like a path with no detours. By simplifying choices, highlighting a single enticing CTA, and making it visually and emotionally compelling, you’ll turn more readers into website visitors ready to buy.
Turning Clicks into Conversions: From Email to Sale
A click is fantastic, but the ultimate goal is a conversion – whether that’s a purchase, sign-up, or other desired action. On average, email conversion rates (the percentage of email recipients who make a purchase) tend to fall in the low single digits (often ~2-5% across industries). The good news is, with targeted tactics, you can beat those averages. Here’s how to convert email engagement into revenue:
Send Targeted, Automated Emails for Key Moments: Not all emails are created equal when it comes to conversion power. Automated trigger emails (like welcome series, cart abandonment reminders, and post-purchase follow-ups) often outperform generic newsletters in driving sales. For example, abandoned cart emails have the highest conversion rate – roughly 3× higher than other campaign types on average. It makes sense: a customer who left an item in their cart is already interested, so a gentle nudge (with maybe a discount or reminder of “low stock”) can seal the deal. Set up automation for critical stages of the customer journey:
Welcome offers for new sign-ups (to turn subscribers into first-time buyers).
Cart recovery emails when someone leaves items in a basket (perhaps offer free shipping or a promo code).
Browse or product view retargeting (if your platform allows, remind shoppers of items or categories they showed interest in).
Post-purchase follow-ups – thank you notes, product review requests, or personalised recommendations to drive the next purchase. Each of these is timely and relevant, which is why they convert better. In fact, one e-commerce brand, Kate Spade, used a two-email automated sequence to boost conversions by 50% and revenue by 174%. They achieved this by listening to customer preferences (via an initial email asking the subscriber to click on their favorite category) and then automatically sending a follow-up showcasing products from that preferred category. It’s a prime example of smart targeting in action.
Highlight Trust and Remove Friction: Once someone clicks through an email, make it as easy as possible for them to complete the desired action. In your emails, address common purchase hesitations upfront. This can be done by featuring trust signals and urgency cues within the email:
Social proof and reviews: Mention customer ratings or testimonials for the featured product (“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 500+ five-star reviews”) to build confidence.
Return policy or guarantee: A short note like “Free returns within 30 days” or “100% satisfaction guarantee” can alleviate fear of commitment.
Scarcity cues: If stock or time is limited, say so! Phrases like “Only 3 left in stock” or “Offer ends at midnight” trigger urgency (more on that in the next section) and can significantly increase conversion likelihood.
Clear pricing and discounts: If you’re giving a discount, show the original price versus sale price (e.g. ~£100~ now £75). This employs anchoring – showing a higher reference price makes the sale price look like a great deal, steering customers toward purchase. Anchoring is a powerful psychological effect: the first price a customer sees sets an expectation, so always display the higher MSRP or “was” price first to frame the value of your offer.
Also ensure that the landing page you send people to fulfills the email’s promise. If the email CTA says “Claim 20% Off,” the click-through should land them on a page where that 20% discount is applied or clearly highlighted – not your generic homepage. Any mismatch creates friction and could cause drop-off. Aim for a seamless journey from inbox to checkout.
Personalised Product Recommendations: Just as personalisation boosts opens and clicks, it can boost conversion by making the purchase feel hand-picked. If you have data on customer preferences or past behavior, use it. For example, include a section in your email like “Recommended for You” with items in categories the subscriber has browsed or bought from before. Emails that employ this kind of personalisation can generate far higher revenue – up to 5.7× more revenue than non-personalised sends. Even simple tactics like dynamically inserting the name of the product left in a shopper’s cart, or showing related items to something they viewed, can make the email more relevant and encourage that all-important click to “Buy Now.”
Create a Sense of Urgency (But Don’t Overdo It): If a subscriber knows they can always buy your product later, they might procrastinate or forget. Urgency and scarcity tactics give them a reason to act now. Use time-limited offers (“Ends tonight”, “24 hours left to claim your discount”) and scarcity messages (“Limited stock – selling fast”) in your emails to spur immediate action. These techniques really work – emphasising urgency can “lead to higher conversion rates and increased website traffic” from your emails. Just be authentic and don’t fabricate false scarcity (consumers can see through fake “Only 2 left!” claims if every email is a last-chance sale). Used sincerely, FOMO (fear of missing out) is a powerful motivator to convert a click into a purchase.
Monitor and Optimise the Whole Funnel: Lastly, remember to track beyond the click – look at conversion metrics like email-attributed sales, conversion rate per email, and revenue per recipient. Industry benchmarks for retail email conversion are around 1–5% (depending on how targeted the campaign is). If you’re below that, experiment with the above tactics. Maybe your abandoned cart email needs a stronger incentive, or your promotional blast could be more segmented by customer type. Continuous improvement doesn’t stop at the click; analyze which emails actually drive sales (and which don’t), then refine your strategy accordingly.
Psychological Triggers That Boost Engagement (Urgency, FOMO, Social Proof & More)
Human psychology plays a huge role in marketing – and email is no exception. By tapping into basic cognitive biases and emotional triggers, you can dramatically increase engagement and persuade subscribers to take action. Here are some psychological marketing techniques especially effective in e-commerce emails:
Urgency & Scarcity (FOMO): People tend to take action when they feel they might miss out on something great. Emails that successfully create a sense of urgency often see higher CTRs and conversions. Phrases like “Sale ends in 4 hours,” “Only 5 left in stock,” or even using countdown timer graphics can light a fire under the reader. This works due to FOMO – the fear of missing out. The recipient thinks, “If I don’t act now, I’ll lose this opportunity.” One study noted that leveraging FOMO through limited-time deals or exclusivity is deeply effective, as it taps into an innate human drive to avoid loss. When using urgency, make it specific and real (e.g., a deadline or low inventory number). Even the visual design can support it – warm colours like red or orange in your email design can subtly reinforce feelings of urgency and excitement. Bottom line: Use urgency ethically to encourage prompt action, and your engagement will likely spike.
Social Proof & Authority: We are social creatures – when we see others vouching for a product or service, we’re more inclined to trust and try it. This is why adding social proof in emails can boost conversion rates by up to 15%. Social proof in email can take many forms:
Testimonials or reviews from real customers (“★★★★★ I love how fast the shipping was! – Jane D.”).
User-generated content, like featuring a happy customer’s photo using your product (with permission).
Statistics showing popularity, e.g. “Join 200,000 subscribers” or “Over 1,000 units sold today!”.
Logos of media outlets or awards (“As seen in Forbes” or “#1 in Customer Satisfaction 2025”).By showcasing that others trust you, you remove uncertainty for the reader. Even subtle cues, like “Bestseller” tags on products in a product recommendation email, can trigger the herd instinct – if others are buying it, I should check it out too. Including some form of social proof near your call-to-action is an excellent way to increase the persuasiveness of your email.
Anchoring & Price Framing: The anchoring effect is a cognitive bias where people rely heavily on the first piece of information (the “anchor”) when making decisions. In pricing, you can use this by always presenting a higher reference price against the actual selling price. For instance, an email might say “High-Performance Blender – Was £249, Now £179 (Save £70).” The £249 serves as an anchor that makes £179 feel like a bargain. This influences perception of value and can impact conversions. You can also anchor by showing a more expensive item first in an email and then a mid-range item – the contrast can nudge customers toward the middle option, which now seems reasonably priced by comparison. The key is to use realistic anchors (like MSRP or a competitor’s price) and always clearly highlight the savings or value difference. Anchoring, done right, helps shoppers feel they’re getting a good deal and encourages purchase decisions.
Emotional Storytelling: Emotional triggers drive action. Emails that tell a short story or paint a vivid scenario can create an emotional connection that makes readers more likely to click and convert. For example, a travel gear retailer might start an email with “Last summer, Sarah missed her flight because her old suitcase jammed... here’s how a carry-on upgrade changed her travel game.” This pulls the reader in emotionally. Nonprofits are masters of this; one campaign saw CTRs above 5% by sharing a heartfelt story that resonated deeply. For e-commerce, you can weave mini-stories around products (how it was crafted, the impact it had on a customer’s life, etc.). Emotional engagement – whether it’s excitement, laughter, or even a bit of anxiety (as in FOMO) – often translates to higher engagement and conversion.
Reciprocity (Free Value First): The principle of reciprocity in psychology says that when we receive something, we feel compelled to give something in return. In email marketing, this means if you offer free value up front, customers are more likely to engage and eventually purchase. This could be a free guide, a useful tip/trick in your newsletter, or a small freebie with their first order. Offering a free resource can boost reader engagement and loyalty by fostering a sense of obligation (subconsciously, they appreciate the gift and stay tuned in). For example, an apparel brand might email a “Winter Style Guide eBook – free download,” which provides genuine value. The recipients not only find it useful (building goodwill), but they’re now more receptive to the follow-up product recommendations because you’ve established a give-and-take relationship.
Using these psychological techniques thoughtfully can significantly influence email performance. However, authenticity and balance are key. Overusing urgency or bombarding people with emotional pleas can cause skepticism or fatigue. The best approach is to sprinkle these principles into your campaigns in a genuine way: highlight real customer stories, promote truly limited offers, demonstrate real popularity of products, and provide real value. When done right, you engage not just the inbox, but the brain and heart of your subscribers – and that’s when the magic happens.
Segmentation and Personalisation: The Power of Relevance
One-size-fits-all email blasts are a thing of the past. Today, segmentation and personalisation are must-haves to drive stronger results. By dividing your audience into meaningful groups and tailoring content to each, you make every email more relevant – and relevance boosts opens, clicks, and conversions across the board. Here’s how to harness the power of personalisation:
By leveraging data on gender, Nike was able to show each segment products and visuals that matched their interests, increasing the likelihood of engagement. This kind of dynamic content adapts an email on the fly (in this case, swapping images and call-to-action text for men’s vs. women’s products) to suit different segments of your list.
Collect and Use Customer Data: The first step is to segment based on attributes or behaviors. Common e-commerce segments include:
Past purchase history – e.g. segment customers who bought category X vs. category Y and showcase related items for each.
Browsing behavior – e.g. one segment for those who viewed a particular product or category (send them an email featuring that category or similar items).
Geography or Seasonality – e.g. promote warm jackets to subscribers in cold regions, and lightweight apparel to those in warmer climates, at the same time.
Engagement level – e.g. a VIP segment of frequent buyers (who might get exclusive offers), or a dormant segment (who might need a win-back discount or a “We miss you” note).
Demographics (if known) – e.g. gender, age group, etc., to tailor imagery or tone (as Nike did above).
Smaller, targeted segments allow you to adapt messaging, offers, and timing to each group. The result is that subscribers feel like you understand their needs, rather than spamming them with everything. It’s not uncommon to see significantly higher CTR and conversion from a well-segmented campaign: customers respond when the content resonates with their interests.
Personalise Content (Beyond First Name): Using a subscriber’s first name in the greeting or subject line can be a nice touch (and can improve open rates), but effective personalisation goes much further. Think about personalising:
Product recommendations: (“Hey John, we thought you’d like these picks for you…” featuring products related to what John bought or browsed).
Content based on past interactions: If a customer always clicks on your tech gadget emails but never your home decor emails, lean into that – send them more tech-focused content.
Offers and incentives: For a high-value segment, maybe a loyalty discount or free expedited shipping is a compelling personal touch. For a lapsed customer, perhaps a “come back” coupon.
Anniversaries or milestones: Emails that celebrate a customer’s birthday, or their one-year anniversary as a subscriber, etc., with a special treat, show that you remember them as individuals.
The effort is worth it – 80% of consumers say they will only engage with an email offer if it’s personalised to their prior interactions with the brand. And marketers have found that tailoring emails can dramatically boost performance: personalised emails drive significantly higher transaction and revenue rates (in one stat, 5.7× revenue as mentioned). It’s the difference between feeling like a nameless face on a list versus feeling like the brand is talking directly to you.
Dynamic Content & Merge Tags: Utilise your email platform’s capabilities for dynamic content. This can be as simple as merge tags for names or as advanced as content blocks that swap in/out based on segment. For example, you could have one email template that shows men’s products to male recipients and women’s products to female recipients (as in the Nike example) – the email pulls in different images or text depending on a subscriber’s profile. Many email service providers make this easy with drag-and-drop conditional content. Start with simple personalisation (like inserting name, past product, or location in the copy) and work your way up to more complex dynamic content as you get comfortable.
Segmentation by Behavior (the Kate Spade approach): The Kate Spade case mentioned earlier is a smart model to emulate. They sent an initial email encouraging subscribers to click on the type of products they were most interested in (e.g. handbags vs. shoes vs. apparel). Depending on what link each person clicked, the follow-up email featured products from that category, tailored to each subscriber’s demonstrated preference. This strategy of behavioral segmentation (segmenting by what people do, not just who they are) led to a huge jump in performance – 174% more revenue and 36% higher CTR for their campaign. You can replicate this idea at any scale: for instance, a cosmetics store might have an email saying “What are you shopping for today?” with three buttons (Makeup, Skincare, Haircare). A click on one triggers a targeted follow-up showcasing top sellers in that category. It’s interactive, customer-driven segmentation in real-time.
Maintain a Human Tone: Personalisation isn’t only about data points – it’s also about tone and empathy. Write your emails as if you’re speaking to one person. Use second-person voice (“you”) a lot. Refer to their relationship with your brand (“Since you enjoyed our summer collection…”). When subscribers feel like you’re a friendly store or helpful expert rather than a faceless company blasting promotions, they’re more likely to engage. This is where segmenting by customer lifecycle can help too – you’d speak differently to a new customer versus a longtime VIP. Tailor your language accordingly, and you’ll build stronger connections.
In short, personalisation at scale is doable and highly effective. It might require some upfront work organising your customer data and planning segmented content, but the payoff is a more engaged list and higher conversions. Segmentation and personalisation make your emails feel more like friendly recommendations and less like random ads – and that can make all the difference in today’s inbox.
Timing, Testing, and Other Tactical Optimisation Tips
Beyond content and psychology, there are several tactical optimisations that can give your e-commerce email performance an extra lift. These include when you send emails, how you test improvements, and ensuring your design works for all users. Let’s round up some key tips:
Find the Optimal Send Frequency: Striking the right balance in how often you email is important. Too many emails can lead to fatigue (or annoy subscribers into unsubscribing), while too few can result in missed opportunities or subscribers forgetting about you. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer – it depends on your audience and the value you provide. Monitor your unsubscribe rates and spam complaints; if they spike, you may be over-mailing. Many brands find a sweet spot at a regular weekly or bi-weekly newsletter, plus the occasional special promotion or trigger email. A good practice is to set expectations on your signup (“Join our weekly update”) so subscribers know what frequency to expect. Also consider allowing subscribers to manage their preferences (e.g., only get sale alerts vs. content newsletters). Remember, consistency can improve engagement – a predictable rhythm (like a favorite TV show airing every Tuesday) keeps your audience warm.
Use Send Time Optimisation: As mentioned earlier, timing can influence open rates. If you have a global list, segment by geography or use tools that send at each recipient’s local peak time. HubSpot’s research suggests mid-morning and early afternoon on weekdays tend to perform well on average, but your audience might behave differently. Look at your past campaign data; do emails sent on Fridays get more clicks? Does 8pm do surprisingly well for your niche? Some email platforms can even auto-adjust send times based on when each user usually opens emails (leveraging machine learning on engagement data). If you don’t have that feature, a simple approach is to split your list into a few groups and send the same email at different times to see which yields the best engagement. And don’t forget to account for time zones.
Continuous A/B Testing: The best email programs are constantly evolving through testing. Make it a habit to A/B test one element in almost every campaign you send. Some high-impact tests to try:
Subject line A vs. B: (e.g. urgency-focused vs. curiosity-focused, or emoji vs. no emoji).
CTA text or colour: (e.g. “Shop Now” vs. “Get Your Deal”, or orange button vs. blue button).
Email length or format: (e.g. a version with a lengthy product showcase vs. a version that’s a short teaser linking to the website).
Images vs. no images: (e.g. test an email with a hero product image against one that’s plain text styled – sometimes simpler can perform better for certain audiences or inboxes).
Offer positioning: (e.g. 10% off vs. free shipping, which gets more clicks/conversions?).
When running tests, change only one variable at a time and ensure you have a big enough sample size for reliable results. Over time, these incremental improvements compound. You’ll identify the subject phrasing that consistently wins, the type of visuals that engage your crowd, and even the optimal layout. For example, through testing you might discover your audience prefers a clear, single-column layout over a fancy multi-column design (which aligns with general best practices for mobile). Or you might find that including a GIF increases CTR by 15% in your case. Treat your email strategy as a living, data-informed process. What works for one brand or industry might not be perfect for you, so let your subscribers’ behavior guide you.
Ensure Mobile Responsiveness: We touched on this but it can’t be overstated – always preview your emails on mobile devices. With nearly half of all emails opened on phones or tablets, a responsive design is non-negotiable. Use a responsive email template that can adapt to different screen sizes. Keep your layout simple (again, typically single-column is safest). Use sufficiently large font sizes (body text 14px or larger, headlines ~22px+). Make links and buttons at least 44px in height (Apple’s guideline for a tappable area) to accommodate finger taps. And be mindful of image file sizes – large images can load slowly on mobile data, potentially losing an impatient user. Many brands adopt a “mobile-first” design approach for email now: design for a small screen first, then ensure it also looks good on desktop. If forced to choose, a clean mobile experience should take priority over an elaborate desktop design.
Maintain Consistent Branding & Tone: Even as you optimise for performance, keep your branding elements consistent. Use the same logo, colour scheme, and brand voice across your emails. This consistency builds recognition and trust. If a subscriber opens your email and it looks vastly different from your website or previous emails, it might create a subconscious disconnect. Consistency doesn’t mean every email looks identical – but it should feel like they all come from the same company. Over time, readers recognise your emails at a glance (which can even help open rates, as your emails become familiar and expected). Trust is crucial for conversion, so you want your emails to reliably reflect your brand’s personality and values, reinforcing that you’re a credible business.
Mind Your Sender Reputation and Deliverability: All the optimisation tips in the world won’t help if your emails don’t reach the inbox. Make sure you follow email deliverability best practices:
Use a verified domain for sending (no generic Gmail/Yahoo sender addresses).
Warm up new IP addresses or domains gradually if you’re starting cold.
Avoid spam trigger words and excessive punctuation (as discussed).
Keep your list clean – regularly remove or reconfirm chronically inactive subscribers and hard bounces.
Provide a clear and easy unsubscribe link (required by law and good for user experience).
Comply with anti-spam laws like CAN-SPAM and GDPR.
A good sender reputation means more of your emails land in the primary inbox tab instead of Promotions or Spam. It’s a foundational aspect: higher deliverability = more eyes on your emails = naturally higher opens, clicks, and conversions. If you notice open rates plummet, investigate deliverability issues or spam filtering.
Use Analytics to Refine Strategy: Finally, be data-driven. Track key metrics for each campaign (open %, CTR, conversion %, revenue per email, unsubscribe %). Look for patterns in what worked and what didn’t. For instance, maybe emails with “Last Chance” in the subject consistently got above-average opens (hinting that urgency works for your audience), or maybe product review emails got low clicks (perhaps the content didn’t entice). Monitor trends over time – are your open rates and CTR improving as you implement new tactics? If not, iterate. Also pay attention to industry benchmarks as rough guideposts. If the average open rate in your industry is 30% and you’re at 20%, that flags opportunity to improve subject lines, list quality, or segmentation. Conversely, if you’re beating averages, focus on maintaining and scaling what’s working.
Tackling these tactical areas ensures you’re not leaving easy wins on the table. It’s about working smarter: sending at the right time, to the right people, with the right content, and continually learning from the results. With these optimisations, you’ll fine-tune your email marketing into an ever-more efficient revenue driver.
Beyond E-commerce: Applying Email Best Practices to Any Business
While we’ve focused on e-commerce, many of these email marketing principles are universal. Whether you run a SaaS company, a nonprofit, a B2B service, or any other type of business, you can adapt these best practices to engage your audience and drive results:
Segment & Personalise for Your Context: Every business can segment its audience. A B2B software firm might segment emails by industry or job role of the recipient, sending different content to CFOs than to IT managers. A nonprofit might segment by donor vs. volunteer. Personalisation is equally powerful outside of retail – using a person’s name, referencing their organisation, or tailoring content to their past interactions (like webinars attended or features used) will boost engagement in any email context. The core idea is the same: relevant emails get better results than generic blasts.
Leverage Psychological Triggers Wisely: Urgency isn’t only for sales – a SaaS could use urgency for a limited-time free trial extension (“Upgrade by Friday to lock in 20% off”). FOMO can work for event-driven emails (“Only 3 seats left for our webinar”). Social proof is huge for service businesses too (client testimonials in emails, user success stories, case studies – all build credibility and prompt action). Even anchoring can apply, say, when offering a discount on a subscription plan by showing the higher monthly vs. new annual pricing. Tailor the psychological technique to the situation: e.g., a charity might use emotional storytelling to drive donations, whereas a B2B might use authority and proof points to drive demo requests.
Optimise Subject Lines & Content for Your Goals: Any business emailing should focus on the reader’s benefit and a clear CTA. For example, an email from a consulting firm might use curiosity in the subject (“Are you making this strategy mistake?”) to improve open rates, then drive clicks to a whitepaper download (with a CTA like “Get the Free Guide”). The principles of clarity, strong CTAs, and mobile-friendly design apply across the board. No one enjoys a cluttered, confusing email, whether it’s selling shoes or inviting you to a conference.
Maintain Trust and Provide Value: Especially outside of straightforward e-commerce transactions, trust is key. Businesses should use email to educate, inform, and genuinely help their audience, not just sell. For instance, a weekly tips newsletter (with no hard sell) can nurture prospects until they’re ready to buy. This aligns with the reciprocity principle – give value first, and the sales will follow. By consistently delivering useful content, you train your audience to open and engage with your emails. Then, when you do have an offer or ask (upgrade now, donate now, etc.), they’re more receptive.
Case in Point – Nonprofits and B2B: As a brief example: Nonprofits often see excellent email engagement when they tell compelling stories and show impact. Their open rates and CTR can even surpass those of commercial emails, because the emotional connection is strong – one nonprofit campaign achieved over a 5% CTR by pairing a heartfelt story with a clear donate CTA. B2B companies, on the other hand, might track metrics like email-sourced lead conversions. They have success by offering value (like reports, how-to guides) via email; one technique is to tease a surprising statistic or insight in the email (to entice the click) and then deliver the full content on a landing page. The formula of understanding your audience’s motivations and tapping into them works in any industry.
In summary, the tactics of good email marketing – knowing your audience, personalising messages, crafting great subject lines, optimising design, and leveraging psychological cues – are highly adaptable. Always align the strategy with your specific audience and goals, but rest assured that investing in these best practices will pay dividends whether you’re selling software, soliciting donations, or nurturing client relationships. Email is a versatile tool in any marketer’s toolbox.
Turning Best Practices into Action
Effective email marketing is part art and part science. As we’ve seen, you need the art of understanding your customer’s psychology and crafting messages that speak to them – and the science of testing, data, and tactical optimisations to continually refine your approach. For e-commerce businesses, applying these best practices can lead to significant gains – more opens, higher click-through rates, and ultimately more sales. And these improvements aren’t theoretical: case studies like Kate Spade’s 174% revenue jump from a personalised campaign and data points like single-call-to-action emails getting 3× the clicks show how powerful these techniques can be.
As you implement these strategies, keep the tone natural and customer-centric. Today’s consumers expect emails that feel human, helpful, and relevant – not like spam or “one size fits all” blasts. Remember to monitor your results and listen to what the numbers (and your subscribers) tell you. If you’re consistently providing value and respecting your audience’s time and interests, you’ll build an engaged email list that drives business on demand.
In the end, great email marketing creates a win-win: your subscribers get offers and content they love, and you get the opens, clicks, and conversions that fuel your growth. Happy emailing, and may your next campaign be your best one yet!
Actionable Takeaways:
Craft subject lines that spark curiosity or urgency (and avoid spammy phrases) to lift open rates.
Simplify your emails with one primary CTA – clear, bold, and placed prominently – to boost clicks.
Use psychological triggers like social proof, scarcity, and anchoring in your copy/design to influence engagement.
Segment your audience and personalise content (product recommendations, dynamic images, special offers) for each group – relevance significantly raises performance.
Test everything from send times to button colors, and iterate based on real data. Continuous improvement is the secret sauce of email marketing success.
Email Campaign Best Practice Checklist
1. Before You Write
Define the goal: Decide the one main action you want readers to take (e.g. shop sale, download guide, book now).
Segment the audience: Select the right group (e.g. recent purchasers, lapsed customers, location-based).
Set timing: Choose optimal send time (typically mid-morning/early afternoon in recipient’s time zone).
Check consistency: Does this align with your usual sending rhythm (e.g. Friday newsletter at 10am)?
2. Subject Line & Preheader
Write a curiosity-driven subject line (tease or question).
Add personalisation if appropriate (first name, recent purchase).
Keep it short (5–7 words) but test longer versions too.
Avoid spammy triggers (all caps, “FREE!!!”, excessive exclamation marks).
Consider emoji or humour if brand-appropriate.
Craft a companion preheader that extends the subject with extra detail/value.
3. Email Body & Content
Lead with benefits – answer “What’s in it for me?” right away.
Use clear, engaging visuals (high-quality images or GIFs).
Add social proof (testimonial, rating, “#1 bestseller”).
Keep layout mobile-friendly: single column, large fonts, thumb-friendly buttons.
Ensure branding consistency (logo, colours, tone, voice).
4. Call-to-Action (CTA)
Decide on ONE primary CTA (avoid competing links).
Place it above the fold and repeat at end for longer emails.
Use a bold button, not just text.
CTA copy should be action-oriented (“Shop Now”, “Claim 20% Off”).
Surround CTA with whitespace to make it pop.
5. Psychology & Persuasion
Add urgency/scarcity if relevant (deadline, “Only 3 left”).
Use anchoring (show original price before sale price).
Include social proof (reviews, popularity stats, UGC).
Tell a mini-story or emotional hook if it fits (e.g. product journey, customer experience).
Provide free value where possible (guides, tips, style inspiration).
6. Deliverability & Compliance
Send from a verified domain (not Gmail/Yahoo).
Double-check for spam triggers.
Provide an easy unsubscribe link.
Confirm GDPR/CAN-SPAM compliance.
Keep list clean (remove bounced/inactive addresses).
7. Testing & Optimisation
Preview & test across devices (especially mobile).
A/B test one variable (subject line, CTA colour, length, imagery).
Use send-time optimisation if your platform supports it.
Track key metrics post-send: open rate, CTR, conversion rate, revenue per email.
Log results and insights into shared performance tracker.
8. After Sending
Review campaign analytics (open %, CTR, conversions, unsubscribes).
Compare against benchmarks (your historical and industry averages).
Document what worked (e.g. urgency in subject line boosted opens by 10%).
Plan improvements for the next campaign.
Comments